by Benedict Bergeron ’29 on October 29, 2026
A&E - Literature
The idea of “ever after” permeates the human imagination. The grand appeal of two lovers living out the rest of their days happily ever after or reaching heaven, wherein you’ll spend eternity in perpetual bliss, has gripped our tastes for more than just one generation. Who wouldn’t want to be with the person who makes them happy forever? This trope is most popular with the “happily” prefix attached. Even so, it forms the endings of almost every children’s book and innumerable, more mature novels of all genres, non-fiction and fiction alike.
A jolly sea shanty recently mellowed my ears as I was shredding a trash-bin-full of loose-leaf papers. I had heard of it once before, but I paid it little mind, since it was presented to me as an upbeat shanty, whereas I prefer slower, more somber pieces. But this rendition, which began playing in my earbuds at random, drew me in, and I believe it matches the tone of the song’s subject matter. This shanty—and I’m sure more than one of you has heard of it, even if you haven’t heard it—is called “The Wellerman,” a New Zealand, nineteenth-century ballad, which has now been popularized into a sea shanty. It tells the story of the Billy O’ Tea whaling ship, fighting a whale and waiting with high hopes for the “sugar and tea and rum.”
I academically prefaced the mundane event of my first encounter with “The Wellerman” because I see it as taking great advantage of the “ever after.” The story of Billy O’ Tea echoes the “ever after,” but reforges its effect for its own purpose. If the appeal of two lovers together forever is so compelling, then how repulsive would the prospect of spending an eternity with a slimy hag or a warty ogre be? “The Wellerman” takes a unique approach, crafting a hopeful “ever after” that ominously has no hope.
We see that the unrelenting captain, driven not by greed but by the “Whaleman’s Creed,” a gritty honor code, will never quit the hunt or back down, even in the face of spending the rest of his life “in tow” behind the great whale. What makes the subtle horror of the song apparent, however, is the chorus:
“Soon may the Wellerman come /
To bring us sugar and tea and rum /
One day, when the tonguing is done /
We’ll take our leave and go”
While catchy, the crew sings about their hope and simultaneously reveals their complacency. The captain will not relent, so they settle for waiting for the rum as the whale pulls them along without any sign of letting up. It is a low, stale kind of horror. They are painfully okay with being towed by the whale forever, yet they continue to cling to the hope of killing the whale so that they can take their “leave and go.” The “ever after” is a “hopelessly ever after,” twinged with the biting knowledge on the listeners’ part that the crew is hugging the delusive phantom of hope.