by Annamarie Piconi ’29 on October 29, 2026
Opinion - Campus
At the end of every semester, something unfortunate happens at Providence College. Students gather their copies of Homer, Dante Alighieri, St. Augustine, and William Shakespeare, books that have survived centuries of human civilization, and return them to the bookstore. Apparently, our conversation with these authors has reached its scheduled conclusion. But can a conversation with Dante really end in December?
PC prides itself on its Catholic and Dominican liberal arts tradition, an education rooted in the pursuit of truth, wisdom, and intellectual formation. Yet I cannot help but wonder whether our textbook rental system reflects the philosophy of education the College professes to uphold. At an institution where the annual cost of attendance approaches $90,000, I find it rather extraordinary that students are expected to pay additional money if they wish to keep the books they have spent an entire semester studying. Under the Friar First Day program, our required course materials are provided for the semester, but rented books must be purchased. For a college that places such an emphasis on the enduring value of the liberal arts, it is contradictory to ask students to pay again for the privilege of continuing their education beyond the classroom.
And perhaps what troubles me most is not even the additional expenses, but what it seems to suggest about the purpose of these books. Are they merely temporary instruments of coursework, useful only until the final exam at the end of each semester? Or are they supposed to become part of the intellectual lives PC claims to cultivate? Surely, at a college devoted to the pursuit of veritas, truth, the books through which we first encounter that truth ought to belong to more than a single semester.
Consider the Development of Western Civilization, or, as most students call it, Civ. This is perhaps the most distinctive expression of PC’s intellectual identity. For four semesters, we encounter the authors and questions that have shaped western thought. We palaestra with the Greeks, grapple with Augustine’s theological inquiries, and discover that humanity has spent centuries arguing over questions we still cannot answer. And then we return the books.
I’ve always thought there was something comical about this arrangement, especially when PC itself celebrates the sentiment, “Done With Civ? Never.” If we are never truly finished with Civ, why does our relationship with its books have a due date? This contradiction extends far beyond Civ.
In English classrooms, we encounter Shakespeare, Fyodor Dostoevsky, and Cormac McCarthy. In theology, we wrestle with St. Thomas Aquinas and Augustine. In philosophy, we confront questions of truth, goodness, and what it means to live well. I think particularly of McCarthy, whose novels seem to demand more of their readers each time they are opened. Some books cannot possibly give us everything they contain upon a first reading. Indeed, some require us to become different people before we can understand them.
And perhaps this is what makes returning to a book so extraordinary. We discover not only what an author has written, but who we have become since reading it. A liberal arts education ought to cultivate precisely this relationship with learning. Ultimately, this is not simply a question of bookstore policy. It is a question of what we believe education accomplishes. A Dominican education devoted to veritas cannot reasonably expect the pursuit of truth to conclude with a final paper or test. We may finish Civ. We may graduate. We may leave Providence. But surely the books should have the opportunity to follow us.