Is it Anti-Catholic to Celebrate Halloween?

by Anthony Beach ’30 on October 29, 2026


Opinion - Society


Now that we’ve officially reached October, all the Halloween decorations have come out, and everyone is thinking about what costumes to wear and how they’re going to celebrate. Personally, I never really understood the appeal of Halloween past maybe eighth grade. Once I stopped being able to get candy for free without receiving dirty looks from adults, I was checked out. One of my hometown friends, however, loves the holiday. She recently sent me a TikTok video that had the words “Jesus knows the difference between devil worship and your kid dressing up as Tinkerbell for candy,” an innocent enough video that I wouldn’t expect to get much backlash. Instead, the comments were filled with opinions about why it is “anti-Catholic” and reasons why Catholics and Christians shouldn’t celebrate the holiday.

According to history.com, Halloween dates back to the ancient Celtic festival of Samhain, which marked the end of warm weather and brought in the dark and cold of the winter, a time often associated with death. “On the night of October 31, they celebrated Samhain, when it was believed that the ghosts of the dead could return to earth.” On Oct. 31, the Celtic people would make sacrifices to Celtic deities and wear costumes during the celebration so as not to be recognized by ghosts. Over time, the land was conquered by the Roman Empire, and by 1000 A.D., the Church had established Nov. 2 as All Souls Day, the day after All Saints Day, also known as All Hallows Day, which was met with a similar celebration to Samhain. Celebrations were held throughout the night for All Hallows, or All Hallows’ Eve, which eventually became Halloween. Along with the European holidays around this time to celebrate the dead, many parts of Latin America celebrate Día de los Muertos, the Day of the Dead, from Oct. 31–Nov. 2. Although it is distinctly different from Halloween and Samhain, it shares many similarities. 

Many Catholics who oppose the holiday make points about it going against the First Commandment “because those rituals appease false gods,” which would be a valid argument if we lived 2000 years ago in Ireland. But no, we live in 2026 in America. The holiday has gone so far from the original purpose of warding off evils and killing animals to give to the dead. One comment on the aforementioned TikTok video says, “using anything other than Jesus’ word to ward off evil is witchcraft. Witchcraft is demonic.” This has to be one of the most brain-dead opinions I have ever heard. As if a little kid going around dressed up like Spider-Man and getting a Milky Way and a KitKat is thinking, “Hell yeah, this will show those evil spirits not to mess with me!” Like, c’mon. I don’t get how someone can believe these claims that it goes against the religion when there are so many religious ties to the holiday. 

The people who say you shouldn’t be dressing up for Halloween are also the people who love Christmas. They freak out the second a tree goes up at Rockefeller Center, but forget that the Christmas tree was also started from a pagan tradition. In Northern Europe, people used evergreen branches to ward off evil spirits. Does that sound familiar?

So, all in all, to answer the question: Is celebrating Halloween anti-Catholic? Hell no. We have strayed so far away from the original meaning of it that it doesn’t even matter anymore. It is no longer about wearing costumes to ward off spirits or do witchcraft, but about dressing up and getting candy from your neighbors or wearing skimpy clothes at a freezing cold party.