Izzy Mignardi ‘27

by Izzy Mignardi ‘27 on October 9, 2025

---

Walking across campus on Wednesday, Oct. 1, you might have seen a proud, beaming fan wearing a Red Sox hoodie, laughing with their friend on the way to Ryan Business School. Twenty feet later, you might have seen a girl with downcast eyes wearing a “New York or Nowhere” trucker hat. Nothing can divide a group of college-age students like playoff baseball.

After the Yankees lost the first game of the series to the Red Sox, some baseball enthusiasts thought the Red Sox had secured the series, since no team has lost Game One and gone on to advance to the ALDS or NLDS since the three-game format was introduced in 2022. Nonetheless, the Yankees won Game Two and Game Three, becoming the first team to break this streak.

Game One started with the Yankees taking the lead in the second inning with a solo home run by Anthony Volpe. An RBI by Masataka Yoshida at the top of the seventh gave Boston the 2–1 lead, which was solidified by Alex Bregman with an RBI double, ending the game with a 3–1 win by Boston. Boston’s Garrett Crochet dominated, allowing only one run and pitching a career high of 117 pitches. Chapman loaded the bases in the bottom of the ninth, but the Yankees failed to score. Max Fried pitched well but was replaced by Luke Weaver, who gave up a two-run single, double, and a walk.

Both Ben Rice and Jazz Chisholm didn’t start in Game One, but are credited with helping the Yankees win Game Two. Rice hit a two-run home run early in the game. Trevor Story tied the game 2–2 in the third inning, and later in the sixth hit a solo home run to tie the game again at 3–3 (after Trent Grisham scored on an RBI single by Aaron Judge, which dropped out of Jarren Duran’s glove). In the eighth, Austin Wells hit an RBI single, allowing Jazz Chisholm to score, giving the Yankees the final 4–3 lead.

The stakes were high in Game Three: win or go home. Rookie pitcher Cam Schlittler pitched a historic game: eight shutout innings, 12 strikeouts, no walks. Although from Massachusetts, he’s proven to be a true Yankee. He said, “I woke up and I was locked in. I knew exactly what I needed to do and go out there, especially against my hometown team. As I told Andy [Pettitte] yesterday, I wasn’t going to let them beat me.”

All four of New York’s runs came in the fourth inning; Amed Rosario and Anthony Volpe each with an RBI single, and Austin Wells hit a grounder to first base, where Nathaniel Lowe errored, which allowed the two more runs. The Yankees thrived on the defensive end, too, particularly with Ryan McMahon’s incredible catch as he flipped over into the Sox dugout.

So, Friday morning rolls around, and the girl in the “New York or Nowhere” hat has more pep in her step despite the hangover from last night’s celebration. The kid in the Red Sox hoodie says, “Good luck in Toronto,” and laughs.

The Yankees will need it. They now face the Blue Jays, and again lost the first game of the series with a devastating score of 10–1.

This article was written prior to the games on Oct. 4 and 6.