Dancing with the Stars: A Controversial Season and We Are Only Halfway Through

by Molly McCormack ’30 on October 29, 2026


A&E - Film & TV


The reality competition show Dancing with the Stars began in 2005 and has gone on for 35 seasons. The hit television series pairs one dancing professional with one celebrity, and they learn a new dance every week, competing against the other pairs for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy. Fans vote from home, and the three judges score their dances, all factoring into who will be sent home that week. From basketball players to bachelors, there is always a recognizable celebrity who makes the show totally enticing. The fan base is huge, and fans share their opinions all over social media. Each season has gained more and more traction, and this current one is no exception. All of the new viewers and dedicated fans have also raised the tensions and pressures. This season, specifically, has had major controversial moments, and it is only halfway done. 

The podcaster and comedian Connor Wood is partnered with pro Rylee Arnold this season. The two have been fan favorites for many, as they are young, funny, and clearly putting in the work. Their dances have continuously received low scores from all three professional judges, despite them doing well. This has caused an uproar on TikTok, with many posts calling out the judges for not giving Wood enough credit, since he comes from zero dance experience. Some harsher judges, like Carrie Ann Inaba, have even received hate on social media for her scoring methods. Wood and Arnold just got their first 8/10 scores in the episode that premiered on Tuesday, Oct. 20. This was a huge moment for them and their fans, as Wood finally got the recognition he deserves after all of the backlash on social media. 

There was another large controversy over the episode that premiered on Oct. 13, as pro Jenna Johnson got told off by Inaba after her performance. Johnson and her partner, Harry Shum Jr. from Grey’s Anatomy, have been an incredible duo this season, consistently being at the top of the leaderboard. However, when they received their critiques from the judges, Inaba got into a heated moment with Johnson, insisting that they had a lift in their dance. Inaba ended up reading out the definition of a lift in dance with an attitude that struck everyone watching at home. This moment exploded almost immediately on TikTok, as videos criticizing Inaba started circulating like wildfire. Johnson’s husband, Val Chmerkovskiy, is also a pro this season. After the rude feedback from Inaba, Chmerkovskiy made a comment on  TikTok that was later deleted, stating, “You almost saw Fresh Prince enter the ballroom last night,” referring to the 2022 Oscars slap between Chris Rock and Will Smith. This comment was seen as an unnecessary act of aggression from the pro, resulting in a one-week suspension from the show. This was huge news to fans and struck up a big debate about whether Chmerkovskiy was making a simple joke that the media took too far, or if the comment was a threat and he should be punished for it. His celebrity partner ended up dancing with another pro to replace him for the episode that aired Oct. 20. During the episode, the show mentioned no explanation as to why Chmerkovskiy was not dancing that week. 

Between the new records of fans voting, the backlash against the judges, and the controversial comments from the pros, this season has already been one to remember. People watching at home have gotten more involved than ever before, posting all of their opinions on social media. This is where a lot of the backlash and drama has begun. Despite the drama of this season, the show does a great job of creating a fun environment for the celebrities, pros, and those watching from home. Each week is an exciting new episode of dances, judging, and eliminations. While the backlash is growing, you can’t deny that the show continues to be successful, reaching new records of viewers by the season.